How to Compare Insurance Quotes from Several Insurers in One Place
Making informed choices: Navigating insurance options in our local market
Last reviewed: 18 November 2026
Yes, you can compare insurance quotes from several South African insurers in one place. Online insurance marketplaces such as Everything.Insure ask for your details once, then show quotes from multiple insurers side by side, and let you buy cover, manage your policies and claim on the same platform. Here is how it works, how it differs from going direct to one insurer, and what to check before you choose a quote.
Your three options for getting insurance quotes
| Route | How it works | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct insurer | You get a quote from one insurer, online or by phone | You already know which insurer you want | You only see one price; comparing means repeating the process with each insurer |
| Traditional broker | A broker gathers quotes for you and advises you | Complex cover, or if you want personal advice | Usually slower, often by phone or email |
| Online insurance marketplace | You enter your details once and compare quotes from several insurers online, with broker support | Comparing price and cover quickly, and keeping all your policies in one place | Make sure the platform is an authorised financial services provider (FSP) |
Everything.Insure is an online insurance marketplace with licensed broker support, run by Everything Insure Digital Intermediaries (Pty) Ltd, an authorised financial services provider (FSP 21271). You can check any provider on the FSCA register.
Which insurers can you compare?
The insurers you can compare depend on the type of cover:
| Cover | Insurers on Everything.Insure |
|---|---|
| Car, bakkie and motorbike, home contents, buildings and portable possessions (all risk) | Hollard Insurance Company and Old Mutual Insure |
| Business insurance | Hollard Insurance Company, Old Mutual Insure, Santam, iTOO and Bryte Insurance Company |
| Gap cover | Infiniti |
Compare quotes for car, bakkie and motorbike insurance, home contents, building insurance, portable possessions, business insurance and gap cover.
How comparing quotes on Everything.Insure works
- Tell us what you want to insure. Enter your details once.
- See quotes side by side. Compare premiums, excess and what is covered.
- Choose and buy online. Your cover can start immediately once you accept a quote and pay.
- Manage everything in one place. View, change, pause or cancel policies, and switch insurers without creating a new profile.
- Claim online. Submit claims anytime and track their status. A licensed consultant is available on 087 095 2823 if you would rather talk to someone.
What to compare: price is only one part of a quote
Two quotes can look similar but pay out very differently. Check these before you choose:
- What is covered, for example comprehensive car cover versus third party, fire and theft, or contents versus building cover.
- Excess: what you pay yourself on each claim. A higher excess lowers your premium but costs you more when you claim. Check for additional excesses, such as for young or recently licensed drivers.
- Sum insured: insure for the real replacement value. If you are underinsured, the insurer can reduce your payout through "average". See Why "Average" and Underinsurance Matter More Than You Think.
- Exclusions and conditions, such as security requirements for your car or home, or limits on cover for unoccupied homes.
- Retail versus market value for cars, which affects what you are paid if your car is written off.
- Payment frequency: monthly debit order or annual premium, and any fees.
To compare fairly, set the same cover type, sum insured and excess across all quotes.
Broker or go direct: which is better?
Going direct makes sense if you have already chosen an insurer and only want its price. A broker or marketplace is better if you want to see several prices, need help understanding the differences, or want help at claim time. An online marketplace gives you both: quick self-service comparison, plus a licensed consultant when you need one.
Frequently asked questions
Can I compare insurance quotes from different insurers in one place in South Africa?
Yes. Online insurance marketplaces such as Everything.Insure let you compare quotes from several insurers after entering your details once. For car and home insurance, Everything.Insure compares Hollard and Old Mutual Insure; for business insurance it compares Hollard, Old Mutual Insure, Santam, iTOO and Bryte.
Can I buy an insurance policy online in South Africa?
Yes. On Everything.Insure you can compare, buy and manage car, home, business and gap cover policies online, and submit claims online.
Is it better to use an insurance broker or go direct to an insurer?
Going direct suits you if you have already chosen an insurer. A broker or online marketplace is better if you want to compare several prices, need help understanding the differences, or want support at claim time.
Can I switch insurers later?
Yes. You can compare quotes at renewal or at any time, and switch insurers on Everything.Insure without creating a new profile.
Compare quotes now or upload your current policy schedule and we will try to find you a better price.
Mishaya Chettiar
Co-Founder and Executive Head: Everything.Insure