Hollard vs Old Mutual Insure Car Insurance: How to Compare Them
Load your details once and see Hollard and Old Mutual Insure side by side. What to compare when you do.
Hollard and Old Mutual Insure are two of South Africa's largest short-term insurers, and both offer comprehensive and more limited car cover. On Everything.Insure you don't have to fill in a quote form for each one. You load your details once, and we show you both insurers' cover options side by side, so you can compare price and cover on exactly the same details.
About the two insurers
Old Mutual Insure is part of the Old Mutual group and one of South Africa's oldest non-life insurers, with a history going back to 1845. It insures cars, homes, businesses and specialist risks.
Hollard was founded in 1980 and is South Africa's largest privately owned insurance group. Besides its own brand, it underwrites cover sold by many partner brands and brokers.
How it works on Everything.Insure
- Enter your car, driver and cover details once.
- See quotes from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure side by side, based on the same information.
- Compare the cover options, excess and extras on each.
- Choose the one that suits you and buy online.
Because both quotes come from the same details, you never end up comparing a quote for one driver or address against a quote for another. What's left to compare is what each insurer offers.
What to look at when you compare
| What to check | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Type of cover | Comprehensive covers accidents, theft, hijacking, fire and damage to other people's property. Third party, fire and theft costs less but won't pay to fix your own car after an accident. |
| Value basis | Retail, market or trade value decides what you're paid if the car is written off or stolen. Retail value pays the most. |
| Basic excess | What you pay yourself on each claim. A lower premium often comes with a higher excess. See how an excess works. |
| Additional excesses | Extra amounts for young or newly licensed drivers, drivers not named on the policy, or theft and hijacking claims. |
| Use of the car | Private use, business use or both. Declaring the wrong use can get a claim rejected. See private and business use explained. |
| Security requirements | Some cars need an approved tracking device before theft and hijacking are covered. |
| Extras | Car hire, roadside assistance, scratch and dent, tyre and rim, and credit shortfall cover are usually optional and priced separately. |
| Claim-free rewards | Some policies pay back part of your premium after a set period without claims. |
If one quote is much cheaper, check the excess, the value basis and the extras first. That's usually where the difference comes from.
Read past the premium
Two quotes with the same premium can pay out differently. Look at the policy wording for the things that matter to you, such as whether you can choose your own repairer, how windscreen claims work and whether you're covered when you drive into neighbouring countries.
Get both quotes in one go
Load your details once on Everything.Insure to see Hollard and Old Mutual Insure car insurance quotes side by side, then buy the one that suits you online. If your car is high value, modified or used for work, our brokers can go through both options with you before you decide.
Get comparative car insurance quotes from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, Hollard or Old Mutual Insure car insurance?
Neither is better for everyone. Premiums and terms depend on your car, your drivers, where you park and the cover you choose, so the simplest way to decide is to load one quote on Everything.Insure and compare both side by side.
Does Old Mutual Insure offer comprehensive car insurance?
Yes. Old Mutual Insure offers comprehensive car insurance as well as more limited options, and you can get a quote online through Everything.Insure.
Do I need to fill in a separate quote for each insurer?
No. On Everything.Insure you load your details once and see car insurance quotes from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure side by side.
Get a Personal.Insure quote in minutes! Compare top insurers like Hollard and Old Mutual Insure and choose the perfect fit.
Get a Quote Now
Mishaya Chettiar
Co-Founder and Executive Head: Everything.Insure