Personal.Insure

How to Compare Car Insurance Quotes Online in South Africa

0

Compare car insurance quotes from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure in one place

Last reviewed: 18 November 2026

The quickest way to compare car insurance quotes in South Africa is an online insurance marketplace. On Everything.Insure you enter your car and driver details once and compare quotes from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure side by side. There is no "best" or "cheapest" car insurer for everyone: the right one depends on your car, where you live, who drives it and how you use it, so comparing quotes is the most reliable way to find the best value for you.

Types of car insurance in South Africa

Cover typeWhat is coveredUsually suits
ComprehensiveYour own car (accident, theft, hijacking, fire, hail and other weather damage) plus damage you cause to other people’s propertyNewer or financed cars. Banks usually require comprehensive cover on financed cars.
Third party, fire and theftDamage you cause to others, plus theft or fire of your own car. Not accident damage to your own car.Older cars where full cover costs too much relative to the car’s value
Third party onlyOnly damage you cause to other people’s vehicles or propertyThe lowest-cost protection for low-value cars

The main difference: comprehensive cover pays to repair or replace your own car after an accident, while third party cover only pays for damage you cause to someone else.

What affects your car insurance premium?

Insurers price each driver differently, so the cheapest insurer for your neighbour may not be cheapest for you. Common factors:

  • Car make, model and value. Cars that are often stolen or expensive to repair cost more to insure.
  • Where you live and park. Your suburb, and whether the car is kept in a garage, behind a gate or in the street overnight.
  • Regular driver. Age, years licensed and claims history. Young and recently licensed drivers often pay more and have additional excesses.
  • How you use the car. Private use only, business use, and how far you drive each month.
  • Security. An approved tracking device or immobiliser may be required, or may lower your premium.
  • Excess. Choosing a higher excess usually lowers your monthly premium.
  • Retail versus market value. Insuring for retail value usually costs a little more but can pay out more if the car is written off.

How to find the cheapest comprehensive car insurance for you

  1. Compare quotes with the same cover type, value and excess.
  2. Check the excess, not just the premium. A low premium with a high or additional excess can cost more when you claim.
  3. Insure the right value. Underinsuring saves a little each month but can reduce your payout.
  4. Be accurate about the regular driver and overnight parking. Incorrect details are a common reason for rejected claims.
  5. Only add the extras you will use, such as car hire, tyre and rim cover, or scratch and dent cover.
  6. Compare again at renewal. Premiums change every year.

Comparing car insurance quotes on Everything.Insure

  • Get quotes from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure in one go, for cars, bakkies and motorbikes.
  • Compare premiums, excess and what is covered side by side.
  • Buy online, with cover that can start immediately.
  • Manage, pause or cancel your cover and claim online. A licensed consultant is available on 087 095 2823.
  • Already insured? Upload your current policy schedule and we will try to find you a better price.

Compare car insurance quotes. For more on comparing different types of cover, see How to Compare Insurance Quotes from Several Insurers in One Place.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best car insurance in South Africa?

There is no single best car insurer for everyone. The best value depends on your car, where you live, your driver profile and the cover you need. Comparing quotes is the most reliable way to find it. On Everything.Insure you can compare Hollard and Old Mutual Insure in one go.

Who has the cheapest comprehensive car insurance in South Africa?

The cheapest insurer differs from driver to driver because each insurer weighs risk factors differently. Compare like-for-like comprehensive quotes, with the same value and excess, to see which is cheapest for you.

What is the difference between comprehensive and third party car insurance?

Comprehensive cover pays to repair or replace your own car after an accident, theft, hijacking, fire or weather damage, and covers damage you cause to others. Third party cover only pays for damage you cause to other people’s vehicles or property.

Is third party car insurance enough?

Third party cover can be enough if your car is low in value and you could afford to replace it yourself. If your car is financed or you could not afford to replace it, comprehensive cover is usually the safer choice.

What is the difference between retail and market value?

Retail value is roughly what a dealer would sell your car for. Market value is the average between trade and retail value. Retail cover usually costs more but pays out more if your car is stolen or written off.

Mishaya Chettiar
Written by
Mishaya Chettiar

Co-Founder and Executive Head: Everything.Insure

[ disqus ]

Get the latest news and updates in your inbox

Not sure where to start? We’re here to help.