How to Choose the Right Insurance Cover in South Africa
Choosing the right insurance cover
Last reviewed: 18 November 2026
To choose the right insurance cover in South Africa, start with the losses you could not afford to pay yourself, then insure those for their real replacement value. For most households that means car insurance, building insurance (if you own your home), household contents and portable possessions cover, plus gap cover alongside medical aid. Compare quotes on cover, excess and exclusions, not just price.
What kind of insurance do you need?
| Your situation | Cover to consider |
|---|---|
| You own or finance a car | Car insurance. Comprehensive cover is usually required on financed cars. |
| You own your home | Building insurance (required by banks on bonded homes) and household contents |
| You rent your home | Household contents insurance |
| You carry valuables outside the home | Portable possessions (all risk) cover for phones, laptops, jewellery and cameras |
| You have medical aid | Gap cover to pay specialist and hospital shortfalls |
| Others depend on your income | Life and disability cover |
| You run a business | Business insurance: property, liability, business interruption, and professional indemnity if you give advice |
Car, home, business and gap cover: what each one protects
- Car insurance: damage to or loss of your car, and damage you cause to others. Choose comprehensive, third party, fire and theft, or third party only. Compare car insurance quotes
- Building insurance: the structure of your home, such as walls, roof and fixed fittings like geysers.
- Household contents insurance: your belongings inside the home. How home insurance works
- Portable possessions (all risk): items you take out of the home.
- Business insurance: your premises, stock, equipment, income and liability. What small businesses need
- Gap cover: the shortfall between what specialists charge and what your medical aid pays. Is gap cover worth it?
How to work out the right sum insured and level of cover
- Building: the cost to rebuild at today’s prices, including professional fees and rubble removal. Not the market value.
- Contents: the cost to replace everything you own with new items. Go room by room.
- Portable items: the replacement value of each item, with proof of value for expensive ones.
- Car: retail or market value. Retail usually costs a little more but pays out more on a write-off.
If you insure for less than the true value, the insurer can reduce your payout through "average". See Why "Average" and Underinsurance Matter More Than You Think.
Reading a policy: exclusions, excess and limits
- Exclusions: what the policy does not cover, such as wear and tear, unoccupied homes beyond a set period, or undisclosed drivers.
- Excess: what you pay yourself on each claim. See What Is an Excess (Deductible) in Insurance?
- Limits and sub-limits: the most the insurer pays, overall or for specific items such as jewellery.
- Conditions: what you must do for cover to apply, for example security requirements or reporting a theft to the police.
Buying online or through a broker: what to consider
Buying direct from one insurer is quick if you already know what you want, but you only see one price. A broker gives advice and compares insurers, but is often slower. An online marketplace combines both: you compare quotes online yourself, with a licensed consultant available when you need help. Read more in How to Compare Insurance Quotes from Several Insurers in One Place.
Compare and get a quote online in one place
On Everything.Insure you can compare car, home and portable possessions cover from Hollard and Old Mutual Insure, business insurance from Hollard, Old Mutual Insure, Santam, iTOO and Bryte, and Infiniti gap cover options, then buy and manage your policies in one place.
Frequently asked questions
What kind of insurance do I need in South Africa?
Most households need car insurance if they own a vehicle, building insurance if they own their home (required by banks on bonded properties), and household contents insurance. Portable possessions (all risk) cover protects items you take out of the home. Many people also add gap cover to their medical aid. Business owners need business insurance suited to their risks.
How do I choose the right insurance cover?
Start with the losses you could not afford to pay yourself, insure them for their real replacement value, choose an excess you can afford, check the exclusions, and compare quotes from more than one insurer with the same cover.
What types of insurance should I have?
The essentials for most South Africans are car insurance (if you own a car), building insurance (if you own your home), household contents insurance and medical aid. Depending on your needs, add portable possessions cover, gap cover, life and disability cover, and business insurance.
Is it better to buy insurance online or through a broker?
Buying online is quick if you know what you need. A broker helps if you want advice or to compare several insurers. An online marketplace such as Everything.Insure gives you both: you compare quotes online, with a licensed consultant available when you need help.
How much cover do I need?
Insure buildings for the cost to rebuild at today’s prices, contents and portable items for what it would cost to replace them new, and cars for retail or market value. Underinsuring can reduce your payout through the "average" clause.
Mishaya Chettiar
Co-Founder and Executive Head: Everything.Insure